{
 "key": "argan",
 "type": "guide",
 "language": "en",
 "url": "https://essaouirajourney.com/argan-cooperatives-essaouira-road-goats/",
 "json": "https://essaouirajourney.com/data/en/pages/argan.json",
 "translations": {
  "en": "https://essaouirajourney.com/argan-cooperatives-essaouira-road-goats/",
  "fr": "https://essaouirajourney.com/fr/cooperatives-argan-route-essaouira-chevres/",
  "es": "https://essaouirajourney.com/es/cooperativas-argan-carretera-essaouira-cabras/"
 },
 "title": "Argan Cooperatives on the Road to Essaouira, and the Goats in the Trees",
 "meta_title": "Argan Cooperatives and Tree Goats on the Essaouira Road",
 "description": "Argan cooperatives on the road to Essaouira: how the oil is made, which stops we could verify, questions to ask, and what reporting says about tree goats.",
 "summary": "Argan cooperatives and goats in trees are the two sights everyone mentions on the road from Marrakech to Essaouira. This guide sets out what we could verify about each, what we could not, and how to decide whether either deserves your time.",
 "updated": "2026-11-09",
 "highlights": [
  "Yield: 32-36 kg of dried fruit, 2-2.5 kg of kernels, 1 litre of oil (Huang 2017)",
  "Only Afous Argan is placed on our road by the map; its 2026 status is unverified",
  "Food oil uses roasted kernels, cosmetic oil unroasted ones",
  "Three separate UNESCO statuses, plus a Moroccan geographical indication from 2009",
  "Research on the women: regular income and freedom of movement, but low pay and little power",
  "Your driver asks whether you would like to stop, with no obligation to buy"
 ],
 "facts": [],
 "itinerary": [],
 "includes": [],
 "excludes": [],
 "faq": [
  {
   "question": "Are there argan cooperatives on the road from Marrakech to Essaouira?",
   "answer": "Yes, but fewer can be confirmed than tours suggest. Of ten names we checked, only Afous Argan, about 20 km from Essaouira, is placed on this road by OpenStreetMap, and its 2026 status is unverified. Mogador, at Ounagha, is probably on the route, from a 2014 report. Marjana is often sold on this route, yet the map places it on the Agadir road."
  },
  {
   "question": "Does your Essaouira trip include a cooperative visit?",
   "answer": "No. Our trip is a private vehicle and driver from Marrakech, transport only, at €180 per vehicle for 1-7 people or €220 for 8-17. Your driver will ask whether you would like to stop at a cooperative, and there is no obligation to buy. Any stop uses part of your day, so you can tell us before you book if you want one."
  },
  {
   "question": "How much fruit does it take to make one litre of argan oil?",
   "answer": "A 2017 study by Huang gives 32 to 36 kg of dried fruit, which yields 2 to 2.5 kg of kernels and then 1 litre of oil. Other sources give 35 or 40 kg. At the rate reported in the same study, cracking that many kernels takes one woman about two to three days."
  },
  {
   "question": "What is the difference between cooking and cosmetic argan oil?",
   "answer": "The kernels. For food oil they are roasted before grinding, which gives a hazelnut taste and a red-brown colour. For cosmetic oil they are not roasted. We found no dated source that gives separate prices for the two, so we cannot tell you what the difference should be. Ask which one you are holding before you buy."
  },
  {
   "question": "Does buying oil at a cooperative help the women who make it?",
   "answer": "It may, but it is not certain. Studies describe real gains, such as regular income and more freedom of movement, alongside low pay, bonuses often not paid and little real power. One study reports that control of the trade has moved to intermediaries. None of this research looked at a cooperative on the road to Essaouira."
  },
  {
   "question": "Can I test at home whether argan oil is pure?",
   "answer": "Not reliably, as far as we can establish. You may hear of tricks using smell, foam, cold or paper, but no scientific source we read validates them. The tests that are documented are laboratory methods. One study found that 4 of 28 products sold as 100% argan were not pure, although the sample was limited."
  },
  {
   "question": "Are the goats in the argan trees real or staged?",
   "answer": "Both descriptions contain some truth. Goats do climb argan trees, and a 2017 study looked at how they spread seeds. National Geographic also reported in 2022 that herds are placed in trees along this road for drivers' tips, with welfare concerns from campaigners and a vet. An animal health official disputed knowing of this. You often cannot tell which you are seeing from a car."
  }
 ],
 "content_markdown": "Almost every description of the drive from Marrakech to Essaouira mentions two roadside sights: women's argan cooperatives and goats standing in trees. Both exist, and both are more complicated than a short stop suggests. This guide explains how the oil is made, what researchers have found about the women who make it, which cooperatives we could place on a map, and what has been reported about the goats. We checked everything on 30 October 2026 using published sources and map data. We did not visit or phone any cooperative, and we say so wherever that limits what we can tell you.\n\nThe Marrakech-road cooperatives below are on the route of our [private day trip from Marrakech to Essaouira](https://essaouirajourney.com/), €180 per vehicle, where any stop is optional. Several of the Agadir-road names lie along the coast road used by our [Essaouira day trip from Agadir](https://essaouirajourney.com/essaouira-day-trip-from-agadir/).\n\n## The argan tree, and what each status really covers\n\nThe argan forest, or *arganeraie*, is the source of everything on this page. Its fruit has a pulp around a hard nut, and inside the nut are the kernels that give the oil. The trees grow slowly: according to National Geographic, they take 7 to 15 years to mature. The forest is also under pressure, as the research further down shows.\n\nTour descriptions tend to run several different labels together, so here they are side by side:\n\n| Status | What it covers | Date | What it does not mean |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| UNESCO World Heritage | The medina of Essaouira, formerly Mogador | 2001 | It does not cover the argan forest, the festivals or the islands |\n| UNESCO biosphere reserve | The argan forest as a territory, 2,560,000 ha according to Huang (2017) | 1998 | It designates a territory, not a product |\n| UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage | Argan, practices and know-how concerning the argan tree, passed on by the women known as argan women | 2014 | It recognises knowledge, not any particular cooperative |\n| Moroccan geographical indication (IGP) Argane, not a UNESCO status | The name and its specification, under ministerial order no. 2816-09 | 20 November 2009 | It is a Moroccan text; we could not confirm recognition by the EU |\n\nThe IGP followed a decision by the national commission on distinctive signs on 21 April 2009, at the request of AMIGHA, an association created in 2008. A 2010 page from the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) says the EU approved it in April 2009. That looks like a confusion with the national decision, and we did not verify it in the European register, so we do not repeat it as fact.\n\nNothing we read makes any of the UNESCO statuses a mark of quality for a bottle. If a seller mentions UNESCO, it is reasonable to ask which status is meant and what it has to do with the oil on the shelf. Our [history of Essaouira](https://essaouirajourney.com/history-of-essaouira-mogador/) covers the World Heritage listing of the medina.\n\n## How is argan oil made?\n\nTraditionally, the pulp is removed, the nuts are cracked with a stone, and the kernels are dried, roasted for food oil, ground, kneaded and pressed by hand. A 2023 scientific review (El Maouardi and colleagues, in *Molecules*) describes the traditional method for food oil:\n\n1. **Remove the pulp** from the fruit.\n2. **Crack the nuts** with a stone to free the kernels.\n3. **Dry the kernels** in the air.\n4. **Roast the kernels.** This step is for food oil only.\n5. **Grind them** on a stone mill into a paste.\n6. **Knead the paste by hand** with a little warm water.\n7. **Press it by hand** to separate the oil. The residue is called press cake.\n\nNot every litre is made this way from start to finish. The same review reports that hand extraction recovers about 30% of the oil, while mechanical pressing recovers about 45% and takes around half an hour per litre in a cooperative. Solvent extraction reaches 50-55%. Cracking is the exception: sources report that attempts to mechanise it have not succeeded, so it remains hand work.\n\nThis matters at a stop. You may watch hand grinding while the bottles on the shelf came from a mechanical press. That is not a fraud in itself, but it is a good reason to ask how the oil you are being offered was made.\n\n## What the yield means for the price\n\nThe most useful figure we found is from Huang's 2017 article in the *International Journal of Intangible Heritage*:\n\n| Input | Output |\n|---|---|\n| 32-36 kg of dried fruit | 2-2.5 kg of kernels |\n| 2-2.5 kg of kernels | 1 litre of oil |\n\nOther sources give 35 kg (Routard, 2014) or 40 kg (Wikipedia, citing the BBC in 2020), which are in the same range. Working time varies far more: 8 to 10 hours per litre in a 2005 study, 10 hours in the 2023 review, about 20 hours according to Routard, and 2 to 3 days in a 2024 study. The difference depends on what each one counts. So no single figure deserves to be quoted as the answer, although the 2005 study does say that cracking takes more than half of the time.\n\nThe same Huang article allows a simple calculation. A woman cracks about 0.8 to 1 kg of kernels a day, and up to 1.5 kg. So the kernels for one litre represent about two to three days of work at the usual rate. Payment was 40-45 DH per kg of kernels in 2016, which means about 80 to 115 DH of cracking pay per litre at that date. These sums are ours. They cover cracking pay only, at 2016 rates, and they are not a price.\n\nWhat can you take from this?\n\n- **A litre carries real costs.** The fruit, the days of cracking and the pressing all have to be paid for before anything else. That is logic, not a price guide, and it does not tell you what a fair price is today.\n- **We cannot give you a current price range.** The only recent figure we found is from Le360 in March 2026, which says a litre can now exceed 700 dirhams, with no distinction by quality or place of sale. Huang reports 240-260 DH wholesale in 2016, and Routard warned against anything under 250 DH in 2014. Those older figures show how far prices have moved, not what you should pay.\n- **Price does not prove purity.** A low price is a reason to ask questions, and a high one is no guarantee. A 2010 WIPO page describes diluted oil, and olive oil coloured with paprika, on sale along the roads near cooperatives. That report is old, and we do not know how common this is today.\n- **Bargaining may be possible.** Routard described prices as negotiable in 2014. We could not confirm that this still holds.\n\nOn purity, the best measurement we found comes from the Quadram Institute, reported in 2020: 4 of 28 products sold as 100% argan were not pure. The sample was limited and may not have been bought in Morocco. The methods that detect this are laboratory ones. You may be told about tricks with smell, foam, cold or paper, but no scientific source we read validates any of them, so we do not offer them as advice.\n\n## What is the difference between cooking and cosmetic argan oil?\n\nFood oil is made from roasted kernels, cosmetic oil from unroasted ones. The difference starts with one step in the process.\n\n| | Food oil | Cosmetic oil |\n|---|---|---|\n| Kernels | Roasted | Not roasted |\n| Character | Hazelnut taste, red-brown colour | Not described in the review we read |\n| Separate price | No dated source | No dated source |\n\nBecause the bottles can sit side by side, ask which one you are holding, and check that the label says so. We found no dated source that gives two separate prices, so we cannot tell you how much more one should cost than the other. We also make no health or beauty claims here, as our research did not cover them.\n\n## What is an argan cooperative?\n\nHuang's study gives the clearest description we found. Women members, 85-95% of the total in the study's figures, do the pulping and cracking. Managers and technicians are often urban and paid a fixed salary. There is an entry fee of varying size, and year-end bonuses depend on profits. We did not research the legal status of cooperatives in Morocco, so this describes practice, not the law.\n\nSome cooperatives also belong to a wider network. The Union des Coopératives des Femmes de l'Arganeraie (UCFA, also called Tissaliwine), based in Agadir, was founded in 1999 by four cooperatives with a Moroccan-German project. It is reported to have 22 cooperatives and about 1,200 women (WECF, 2019), while another source says 18. The provinces cited are in Souss-Massa. We found no list of members, so we cannot say that any cooperative on the road to Essaouira belongs to it.\n\nA cooperative is not automatically a charity, and the word on the sign does not tell you how a business works. In 2014, Routard described what it saw as signs of a commercial stop rather than a true cooperative: salaried staff, products made elsewhere, a site designed for coaches, staged production and high prices. That is the opinion of one guidebook, but travellers on its forum report a similar impression of some coach stops.\n\n## Do the women really benefit?\n\nThe fair answer from the research is yes, partly. Here is what we found, and how much of it we were able to read:\n\n| Study | What it reports | Limits |\n|---|---|---|\n| Huang, 2017 | Pay per kg of kernels rose from 25 DH (2002) to 30-35 (2013) and 40-45 (2016). Average income 1,000-1,200 DH a month, from 500 to 1,600. Bonuses often unpaid in recent years, literacy classes in decline, members treated more like employees. Women valued being able to travel without a chaperone | Interviews at 3 cooperatives, 2013 and 2016 |\n| Montanari, Handaine and Id Bourrous, 2023, *Human Ecology* | Control of the trade has moved to intermediaries who supply large groups, threatening cooperatives and women's income | Abstract only; interviews with cooperative managers; one co-author directs the UCFA |\n| Lybbert and colleagues, 2011, *PNAS* | Households with access to the fruit gained, and sent more daughters to secondary school. But they also bought goats and harvested harder, so higher prices did not help the forest and may have sped up its decline | Surveys and satellite imagery, 1981-2009 |\n| Life-cycle study, 2024, *Int J Life Cycle Assessment* | Women working at home earn more per day than cooperative workers, both below the legal minimum wage | Search excerpt only; treat with caution |\n\nTwo more limits apply. Work by le Polain de Waroux and colleagues asks the same questions, but we did not read its conclusions. And all these studies concern Souss-Massa or the argan region in general: none looks at a cooperative on our road.\n\nSo buying at a cooperative may help, but it is not a certainty, and we would distrust any stop that promises you it is. Claims that all the profit goes to the women are not supported by anything we read.\n\n## How to judge a stop: questions to ask\n\nWe cannot give you a test for a good cooperative, and no answer below is proof. But these are fair questions, and how they are answered tells you something.\n\n| Ask | Why it helps |\n|---|---|\n| How many women are members here, and do they work on site today? | Separates members from salaried staff, a distinction Routard raised |\n| How are the women paid: per kg of kernels, by the month, or both? | Huang's study found pay by the kg, so this question has a real answer |\n| Were bonuses paid last year? | Huang's study found they were often not |\n| Is this oil pressed here? By hand or by machine? | A demonstration does not always show how the bottle was made |\n| Is this bottle roasted or unroasted? | It decides whether it is food or cosmetic oil |\n| Does this product carry the Argane IGP? | It is the formal Moroccan indication, and a plain yes or no is easy to give |\n| Where do you get the fruit? | A clear answer shows knowledge of the supply |\n| Is there a printed price list? | You can compare without pressure |\n| May I look around without buying anything? | You should be able to leave freely |\n\nIf the person showing you round is happy with these questions, that is a good sign, but not a guarantee. If they are brushed aside, you have learned what you need, and you can leave.\n\n## The named cooperatives: what we could and could not verify\n\nWe did not call any of them, and we read no published opening hours. No first-rank source from 2026 confirms that any of them is still open. This table is what the sources say. It is not a list of recommendations.\n\n| Cooperative | Where the sources put it | On the Marrakech road? | What we could not verify |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| **Afous Argan** | OpenStreetMap: Km 20, on the N8, at 31.53256, -9.59336. An undated review: 20 km from Essaouira on the Marrakech road | **Yes, the only one confirmed by the map** | Whether it was open in 2026. A review mentions a guide, an explanation of the process and a shop; one weak source mentions free entry and 30-60 minutes |\n| **Mogador** | Ounagha, about 30 women (Routard, 2014) | Probably: Ounagha is on the route, exact point unknown | Everything since 2014, including whether it takes visitors |\n| **Tiguemine** | About 15 km from Essaouira, direction not stated (Routard, 2014) | Unknown | Location on a map, visits |\n| **Assafar** | Near Essaouira (Routard, 2014) | Unknown | Location on a map, visits |\n| **Marjana** | **In conflict.** OpenStreetMap: Agadir road, Sidi H'Mad, 31.34572, -9.71141. Listings: R207, Douar Ait Sraidi Lhararta. One Agadir blog: Tamanar | **According to OpenStreetMap, no**, although many tours sell it on this route | Exact location, and the headcount (60 or 80 women). Demonstration and shop are described in listings and reviews |\n| **Ajddigue** | Tidzi, Agadir road; about 100 women (Routard, 2014) | **No** | Visits. Studied by Huang |\n| **Tamounte** | Imi N'Tlit, 57 km south; about 50 women (Routard, 2014) | **No** | Visits |\n| **Amal** | Tamanar; presented as the first run entirely by women (WIPO, 2010) | **No** | Visits. Studied by Huang |\n| **Tighanimine** | Not located | Unknown | Location, visits. Studied by Huang |\n| **Agdal Merk Takouche** | Essaouira province, a signatory in the UNESCO file; exact location unknown | Unknown | Location, visits |\n\nIf a tour lists Marjana as a stop on the road from Marrakech, ask where it is on a map. It may be a real place and still mean a detour or a different route. None of this says anything about the quality of any of these cooperatives, only about where we can place them.\n\n## Do goats really climb argan trees?\n\nYes, goats do climb argan trees, although not everything you see by the road is natural. The goat stop is the one thing about this road that is easy to misread, so it helps to separate the facts.\n\n**The climbing is real.** Goats do go up argan trees. A 2017 study by Delibes, Castañeda and Fedriani, described as preliminary, found that they regurgitate seeds while ruminating, and more than 71% of those seeds remained viable. Herders also prune the trees to make climbing easier.\n\n**The display is documented.** National Geographic reported on 6 June 2022 that nine separate herds could be seen in trees along this road. They were out mainly in the middle of the day, when traffic is heaviest, and drivers tipped. Herders said they began during the drought. One herder said some drivers give 10 DH and others 10 dollars, about 20 dollars on a good day before the pandemic from around ten vehicles, and that during lockdown 13 goats fell to one because the others starved.\n\n**The welfare criticism is serious.** In the same article, World Animal Protection and a vet raise concerns about heat stress, dehydration and falls, and campaigners describe the animals as exploited. A 2019 report in The Telegraph, which we read only through another publication's summary, cited Born Free calling the site a tourist trap, with goats sometimes tied and platforms reported.\n\n**It is also disputed.** Asma Kamili, of the animal health division, told National Geographic of having no knowledge of goats being placed for money, and spoke of natural behaviour. So neither claim holds alone: goats do not climb only for show, and not everything you see is natural.\n\n**It is not good for the trees.** Fedriani told National Geographic that goats also eat leaves and young shoots, which does the trees no favours, and Lybbert's study names goats as the main threat to the forest.\n\n### What a responsible visitor can do\n\nWe found no official guidance, and National Geographic gives none. What follows is our own deduction, not a rule.\n\n- **Do not pay for a photo, above all if an animal seems to be tied.** Money is the documented reason for the display.\n- **Look from the vehicle if you want to look.** You often cannot tell a natural scene from a staged one at that distance, and you do not need to stop to see it.\n- **Do not intervene.** We found no verified way to report a case. One Morocco blog suggests going through local associations rather than acting yourself.\n- **Remember the other side.** The same report shows herders who depend on this small income, so this is a question about animals and about people.\n\n## A cooperative stop on a private trip with us\n\nOur [private trip from Marrakech](https://essaouirajourney.com/) is a vehicle and driver for your group: €180 per vehicle for 1 to 7 people, €220 for 8 to 17, transport only. No cooperative visit, guide, entry or purchase is part of the price.\n\n- **Cooperative stops.** Your driver will ask whether you would like to stop, and there is no obligation to buy. This page recommends no cooperative. Because we have not confirmed that any is open, treat a stop as a possibility, not a promise.\n- **Goats.** We do not stop for them unless you want to. If you do, whether to pay anything is your decision, and we hope you will read the section above first.\n- **Time.** The [road from Marrakech](https://essaouirajourney.com/marrakech-to-essaouira-road-distance/) takes about 2 h 45 to 3 h without stops. A stop on the way out reduces your time in town, which is about five hours, and our [one-day route](https://essaouirajourney.com/what-to-do-in-essaouira-in-one-day/) shows what that time covers. A stop on the way back brings you home later, and on a typical day from October to February a good part of the end of the drive is already after dark. If you already know you want a stop, tell us on WhatsApp before you book.\n\n## What we could not confirm\n\n- **Whether any cooperative on this road was open in 2026**, Afous Argan included.\n- **Whether any cooperative on this road belongs to the UCFA.** We found no list of members.\n- **A current price range for a litre**, or separate prices for food and cosmetic oil.\n- **Any research on a cooperative on this road.** All the studies we found cover Souss-Massa or the argan region in general.\n- **How the goats are treated today.** The main report dates from 2022, and we made no visit.\n\nIf you have visited one of these cooperatives recently, or know of a change, tell us and we will correct this page. For practical questions, see our [FAQ](https://essaouirajourney.com/faq/), and you can [book online](https://essaouirajourney.com/book-essaouira-day-trip/) in a few minutes.\n\n## Sources\n\nConsulted on 30 October 2026. We did not visit or phone anyone. Some pages were read through a summarising tool, so we paraphrase them rather than quote; those marked as an excerpt or abstract were not read in full. Map positions come from OpenStreetMap via Nominatim.\n\n- [Huang, International Journal of Intangible Heritage, 2017](https://www.ijih.org/volumes/article/668)\n- [El Maouardi and colleagues, Molecules, 15 February 2023](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9966767/)\n- [Rahmani, Cahiers Agricultures, 2005](https://revues.cirad.fr/index.php/cahiers-agricultures/article/download/30539/30299/30774)\n- [Montanari, Handaine and Id Bourrous, Human Ecology, 2023](https://ciencia.iscte-iul.pt/publications/argan-oil-trade-and-access-to-benefit-sharing-a-matter-of-economic-survival-for-rural-women--of-the/93965?lang=en) (abstract only)\n- [Lybbert and colleagues, PNAS, 2011](https://data.landportal.info/node/38768)\n- [Life-cycle study, International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 2024](https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11367-024-02412-9) (search excerpt only)\n- [UNESCO, Argan, practices and know-how concerning the argan tree](https://ich.unesco.org/en/RL/argan-practices-and-know-how-concerning-the-argan-tree-00955) and [Decision 9.COM 10.30](https://ich.unesco.org/en/decisions/9.COM/10.30)\n- [UNESCO World Heritage decision on the medina, 25 COM X.A](https://whc.unesco.org/en/decisions/2301) and [UNESCO file of consents](https://ich.unesco.org/doc/src/20305.pdf) (excerpts)\n- [Ministerial order no. 2816-09, WIPO Lex](https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/legislation/details/20608) and [AMIGHA, ORIGIN](https://www.origin-gi.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/5_MAROC_AMIGHA_ORIGIN.pdf) (excerpts)\n- [WIPO on the Argane geographical indication, 2010](https://www.wipo.int/fr/web/ip-advantage/w/stories/protecting-society-and-the-environment-with-a-geographical-indication)\n- [Routard, report on argan oil, 26 June 2014](https://www.routard.com/fr/mag/reportage/a/l-huile-d-argan-l-elixir-marocain) and [Routard forum](https://www.routard.com/forums/t/recherche-huile-dargan-a-marrakech/141566)\n- [Le360 on argan oil, 22 March 2026](https://fr.le360.ma/economie/or-liquide-du-souss-lhuile-dargan-un-tresor-marocain-qui-seduit-au-dela-des-frontieres_SYO64C7WGBAXTAIUUYPQJEJWVA/)\n- [NutraIngredients on the Quadram authenticity test, 9 April 2020](https://www.nutraingredients.com/Article/2020/04/09/Scientists-develop-argan-oil-authenticity-test/)\n- [WECF on argan cooperatives, 10 March 2019](https://www.wecf.org/best-practice-example-alternative-finance-models-for-argan-oil-cooperatives-in-morocco/) and [International Cooperative Alliance](https://ica.coop/en/newsroom/news/womens-co-ops-around-world) (excerpts)\n- [Monnuage on Afous Argan, undated](https://www.monnuage.fr/point-d-interet/cooperative-a34044) and [Nomadotravel](https://www.nomadotravel.app/fr/attractions/argan-oil-cooperatives) (excerpts, weak sources)\n- [Tripadvisor on Marjana](https://www.tripadvisor.co.uk/Attraction_Review-g298349-d9834417-Reviews-Cooperative_Marjana_ARGAN_OIL-Essaouira_Marrakech_Safi.html), [Headout](https://www.headout.com/day-trips/from-marrakech-essaouira-day-trip-with-argan-cooperative-visit-e-56158/) and [Agadir Car Rentals blog](https://agadircarrentals.com/blog/argan-oil-cooperatives-near-agadir) (excerpts)\n- [National Geographic, 6 June 2022](https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/moroccos-tree-climbing-goats)\n- [Ecological Society of America on goats and seeds, 24 May 2017](https://esa.org/esablog/2017/05/24/tree-climbing-goats-disperse-seeds-by-spitting/) (excerpt)\n- [Luxury Travel Advisor on the 2019 Telegraph report](https://www.luxurytraveladvisor.com/destinations/too-goat-to-be-true-morocco-tourist-site-where-goats-climb-tree-exploitative-scam) and [Malika in Morocco](https://malika-in-morocco.com/?p=4866) (excerpts)"
}